When You Have Too Much of a Good Thing

Onion. When You Have Too Much of a Good Thing
“Peeling the Onion”

In general, our belongings should be things we use, need, or love. It is common to accumulate more of the things that bring us special joy than those that are simply utilitarian. However, even things we love can pile up and become overwhelming. When this happens, we end up having too much of a good thing.

Over-accumulation occurs for a variety of reasons:

  • We struggle to resist buying things we love, even when we already have a lot.
  • We are better at purchasing than we are at purging.
  • We can’t find things we own and keep buying replacements.
  • Friends/family hear we love a certain thing (frogs, flags, corkscrews, postcards, etc.), and give them to us as gifts.

Whatever the reason, having more than we can manage makes it hard to enjoy.

Often, we reach a breaking point and want to get things back under control, but perhaps have no idea how to even begin. When there is a significant quantity, “normal” decluttering approaches may not work.

For example…

  • If you have books all over the house, doubled up on your bookshelves, piled on the floor, boxed up in the basement, and otherwise stashed throughout the house, gathering them all together to one sorting location is not practical.
  • If you have clothing filling closets throughout the house, hanging out of your drawers, in containers under beds, in bags in the attic, and on free-standing racks in the bedroom, it may be impossible to gather all of your shoes together and decide which ones you want to keep.
  • If you have boxes of paperwork going back years and all muddled together, you may not be able to use the OHIO (Only Handle It Once) approach.

When a given category of belongings has grown to the point of permeating multiple locations, perhaps even resulting in limited free space for processing, I suggest what I call the “peeling the onion” approach.

If you have ever handled an onion, you know that the skin has multiple layers. On the outside, the skin is typically quite dry. This layer comes off quickly and easily. In fact, sometimes it falls off as you carry the onion to your counter for shopping. Taking off the outer layer of an onion requires practically no effort. As you go deeper, the skins become softer, and also more difficult to remove. You might need to do a bit of prying or cutting to get it off. It’s only once the outer layers are removed that you are able to cook the fresh, edible portion inside.

Bearing this image in mind, when working through a particularly complex decluttering project, I find it helpful to work through the situation in layers.

Let’s look at the example of having a lot of clothing.

If you are drowning in clothing, you are not yet ready to start buying fancy hangers and deciding what to store where. First, you need to reduce the amount you have. Ultimately, the goal is to match the quantity of your belongings to your available storage space. In the case of clothing, this doesn’t necessarily mean everything needs to go into a solitary closet or set of drawers, but it should fit in a way that allows you to see and access what you want. Admittedly, this may include some bins for out of season clothing, or a cedar closet for lesser worn garments. Nevertheless, all clothing should be stored in a manner that is predictable and safe.

Round One

So where do we begin? It is easiest to start with whatever is most accessible and work your way in. For instance, if you have items on the floor or hanging in front of other items, start with these. In Round One, the secret is speed. Our goal is to simply remove the outer layer of the onion, the “low hanging fruit.” Take a look at each item and make a quick decision. If you find yourself equivocating over an piece, keep it. You will be doing a second sweep in the future. At that point, you will have a better idea of what you have and making a decision may feel easier.

Regardless of where you start, it is critical to work sequentially. Don’t look at a shirt on the floor, and then turn and look at one up on a shelf, and then look at a piece hanging on a rod. Start in one spot, look at every piece as you go along. Again, this isn’t meant to be stressful. Simply go through items and remove anything you can easily let go.

There are two major objectives for “Round One:”

  • Remind yourself of what you have
  • Free up space for a more thorough review in “Round Two”

Keep moving along, one space after another. Round 1 may take a fair amount of time. You won’t get it done in a day. The key with large projects is consistency, so set regular times when you will continue to review. For example, you might try working for 15 minutes a day, or set aside a couple of hours each Saturday morning.

After each session, remove any of the items that you have decided to shed. Don’t neglect this step! Move them to a location in the garage, or even put them in your car. Depending on what things you have, you can probably find a charity who will accept the pieces you no longer want. Another great method for shedding unwanted belongings is to schedule a pickup by a charity. I suggest that you schedule a bunch of pickups, because knowing that someone will be showing up to retrieve your donations can help keep you motivated to move forward.

Sometimes we come across items that we would like to give to someone in particular. This is perfectly fine, as long as you can get them to the intended recipient in a timely fashion. What you want to avoid is having bags or piles for someone that you won’t see for more than a couple of weeks because their presence will undermine the second goal of Round One.

Round Two

After you have done a first pass on all of the pieces, you are ready to move on to Round Two. You should now have more space for processing, as well as a clearer idea of what you own. If, after Round One, you still have very little space to move around, I suggest you bring in a professional organizer to support you. Remember, there is no shame in getting help. In fact, securing needed resources is one of the smartest (and often financially wisest) things we can do when facing a difficult situation.

If you have made decent progress on Round One, Round Two can now proceed like a traditional decluttering project. Identify a location where you will bring items for review. Going back to the clothing example, this could be a nearby bed. Smaller/more fragile items are better suited to be reviewed on a clear table. If you don’t have a free table, consider setting up a folding table for sorting wherever you are working. However, remember that a sorting table is not a storage location. It is a place to make decisions. Be sure to either clear this table or collapse it at the end of each sorting session.

Once you have designated a sorting location, start bringing items to this location for review. If your items are spread all over your home, you can work in one room at a time. Put like items together to help you make decisions. For clothing, this might include trousers, jeans, blouses, knit tops, sweatshirts, socks, shoes, etc. Review each category with the goal of removing another layer of this “onion skin.” A few things to remember at this stage:

  • Depending on how much you have, you may choose to work on one category per session.
  • It helps to be realistic. For instance, we may love a pair of jeans, but honestly can no longer fit into them. Let go of items that cannot (or are unlikely to) be a part of your current life. The goal is to prioritize what we love and use now, as opposed to what we may use someday.
  • Things you want to keep purely for sentimental reasons are candidates for remote storage. For instance, a letterman jacket from high school can go into a memorabilia bin, rather than hung in your closet.
  • You may have some items that need further processing, such as a dress that you need to try on, or a jacket that belongs to someone else with whom you need to check before donating. Set these items aside in a “homework” pile to be addressed before your next sorting session.
  • You may have items that you feel guilty shedding because they were gifts, or you spent a lot of money on them. These are never good reasons to keep things.

After Round Two, you should now have a quantity that more accurately matches your storage capacity. This is the time to design an organizing strategy, including furniture, shelving, containers, hangers, etc.

I’ve used clothing as an example in this post, but you may be overwhelmed by any number of belongings, including sports gear, photos, books, art, tools, hats, or many other things. Regardless of the item, the approach to thin them out is the same.

Also, depending on what you have, how you are feeling, and your capabilities, you might need special assistance to help you declutter, such as from:

  • A professional organizer
  • An accountant
  • A photo organizer
  • Someone physically strong, to reach and carry heavy items
  • A junk hauler
  • A mental health professional
  • An accountability partner or body double
  • A friend

*     *     *

When what was meant to be fun feels more like a burden than a joy, it is time to declutter. Do you think that “peeling the onion” might help you proceed?

Seana's signature

22 thoughts on “When You Have Too Much of a Good Thing”

  1. One of my clients liked to approach all editing areas with a “first pass.” It helped her let go of the easy things or “low hanging fruit” as you called it, see visible progress, and not get stuck on trickier items. If she wasn’t sure, it gave her great comfort and confidence to say, “This is my first pass.” She knew she’d return from round two or three, but in the first sweep a lot was always accomplished and released.

    I love how you describe the process as peeling back layers back like an onion… a wonderful analogy!

    1. I’ve also had a couple of people who weren’t ready to experience the pressure of having to decide about everything in one pass. Of course, time is required for this approach, but for some situations, I think it can make things easier.

  2. I love the reframing of clutter here – that it is too much of a good thing. That is how my clients see their stuff. It is all good! And when it is good, that’s hard to let go. I often ask, no matter if it is good, what is the best use of so many when you have too much for yourself? I love the idea of peeling off the onion in layers.

    1. It’s so easy to just let items accumulate on that table, right? The “I’m not sure” pieces? They can stay for a moment, if necessary, but that surface must be cleared by the end of the session so we can start again fresh.

  3. I am a fan of this peel-the-onion approach. As humans, we are creatures of habit and can easily get comfortable with the things around us. This approach will help break the crystallization that happens when we see things in place for a long period of time.

    In this fast-paced world, when people want instant gratification, it may be a problem for people to do that when there is too much stuff. So, your method helps them slow down and realize what they have and connect to what they want to do next. Thanks for sharing.
    Sabrina Quairoli recently posted…How to Create a Holiday Season Planner to Save Money and TimeMy Profile

  4. When there is too much of a good thing and just too much stuff…..then nothing is special anymore. It might not be displayed in a nice way, harder to find or see things, and harder to make decisions about what to wear (for example) I love the analogy of the onion – it makes so much sense that sometimes we need to make it a process. I know that I do when it comes to clothing which I am planning to tackle this week.

    1. I’ve been with a couple of clients recently who have so much, we have to proceed in small steps. Using this approach has helped to alleviate tension and make the process feel both manageable and pleasant! A win/win for sure. 🙂

  5. I love the way you frame this, and I agree with everything that you’ve said. I’m particularly gratified that you pointed out that people can’t necessarily deal with all of their clothes at once; that has always been my problem with the Kondo approach.

    I called peeling an onion, “a Level One purge.” It gives people a chance to gain the skills necessary for further decluttering. You have explained the process perfectly.
    Julie Bestry recently posted…Paper Doll Helps You Get By With a Little Help From Her (Brilliant) FriendsMy Profile

    1. Level One purge is exactly the idea. You don’t have to feel like it is “all or nothing,” which in some cases is simply unrealistic. If you live in a tiny apartment you might be able to do that, but if you have 5 bedrooms and attics and guest rooms and antechamber, that might just be a bit much!

    1. Exactly, Janet. Sometimes we can look at a mountain and think we have no chance of scaling it, so why bother? But it can be pretty astounding to see what we can accomplish little by little.

      Organizing doesn’t have to be a “one and done” process, especially for situations where there is a lot to review.

  6. I am inspired to get started “peeling the onion” and I have many, many, areas that need this attention. It is clothing I want to do first. I need to set aside aa day when I do nothing else-keep my calendar free-and start! Thanks for the nudge.

    1. Good luck, Dianne! And if you need to take more than one day, that’s okay as well. Just keep at it consistently until you are content with the results.

    1. There are times when the old “OHIO” method just doesn’t work well. I find most people gain confidence as they make more and more decisions, meaning round 2 feels easier than round 1. It’s all about customizing an approach for each person, right Jill?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.